I go through peanut butter at an almost embarrassing rate, so buying tiny jars over and over drives me nuts (pun intended). Enter the One Trick Pony 8 lb Peanut Butter Tub — a bulk answer for serious PB devotees. Here’s my honest review.
It’s exactly what it sounds like: a single 8 lb plastic tub of peanut butter — about 113 servings. One Trick Pony keeps the ingredient list refreshingly short: organic Argentinian roasted peanuts and salt. That’s it. You choose between “Crazy Crunchy” and “Silky Smooth.”
The two-ingredient approach is the whole appeal. No palm oil, no added sugar, no emulsifiers — just organic peanuts and salt. The Argentinian peanuts give it a rich, roasted flavor, and because there are no stabilizers, it’s a natural peanut butter (expect some oil separation to stir in).
Eight pounds is a lot of peanut butter, and that’s the point. For families, athletes hitting protein goals, meal-preppers, or anyone who eats PB daily, buying in bulk means fewer reorders and less packaging waste versus a stack of small jars.
As a natural, no-stabilizer peanut butter, you’ll want to stir the separated oil back in, and an 8 lb tub is easiest to manage if you decant some into a smaller jar for daily use. Store it cool to keep it fresh over its long life.
At $60 for 8 lbs (113 servings), it works out to roughly $7.50 per pound — strong value for a clean, organic, two-ingredient peanut butter, especially compared with buying premium natural PB in small jars.
✅ Just two ingredients: organic peanuts + salt
✅ Huge 8 lb / 113-serving value
✅ Crunchy or smooth, rich roasted flavor
❌ Natural PB separates — needs stirring
❌ 8 lbs is a commitment if you’re a light user
If peanut butter is a staple in your house, the One Trick Pony 8 lb tub is a smart, clean-ingredient way to buy it in bulk and save. It’s only overkill if you’re a casual PB eater — for everyone else, it’s an easy recommendation.
Q: What’s in it?
A: Just two ingredients — organic Argentinian roasted peanuts and salt.
Q: How big is the tub?
A: 8 lbs, about 113 servings, in one plastic tub.
Q: Crunchy or smooth?
A: You can choose Crazy Crunchy or Silky Smooth.
Q: Does it separate?
A: Yes — it’s natural with no stabilizers, so stir the oil back in.
Q: How much does it cost?
A: $60 for the 8 lb tub when I viewed it.
You can check current pricing and flavors here: One Trick Pony 8 lb Peanut Butter Tub.
Affiliate disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
#OneTrickPony #PeanutButter #BulkPeanutButter #OrganicPeanutButter #NaturalPeanutButter #PBLife #CleanEating #TwoIngredients #HighProtein #Foodie #PeanutButterDeals #PantryStaple
